An X-ray crystal structure of DDK in association with both DDK inhibitors has been solved recently . The tighter binding of XL413 in the binding pocket of DDK along with its more extensive associations with the non-conserved residues of the active site is thought to be the reason for the superior selectivity profile of XL413. The cellular potency data provided with the initial characterization of XL413 along with the crystal structure evidence made it the best in class DDK inhibitor. XL413 seemed an ideal chemical probe for studies of DDK function in normal and in tumor cells. It was therefore surprising that in most cell lines we tested XL413 fared very poorly when compared to PHA-767491. This led us to perform a comparative analysis of the biochemical characteristics of both inhibitors. Both inhibitors were quite effective in inhibiting purified DDK complex in vitro. Although the cancer cell lines had varying 1338247-30-5 structure levels of DDK, they all responded well to PHA-767491. XL413, however, had almost no effect on nine of the ten cell lines in our panel. It also did not induce cell cycle arrest in majority of cell lines, indicating that DDK activity was not being inhibited in vivo. This was corroborated by the Mcm2 phosphorylation analysis in 33996-33-7 XL413-sensitive Colo-205 cells and XL413-resistant HCC1954 cells. The majority of the original cellular potency profile for XL413 was provided with one cell line, Colo-205. In our analysis, Colo-205 was the sole cell line highly responsive to XL413. Taken together, our analyses suggest that XL413, while exhibiting impressive chemical characteristics and selectivity, is a poor chemical probe for cell lines. As described by Workman and Collins , the effectiveness of an inhibitor as a chemical probe is dependent on its chemical properties biological potency biological selectivity and its context of use. Since XL413 is a product of a high throughput drug-screening program and must have satisfied multiple criteria for selection as lead compound, it is expected to exhibit good pharmacokinetic properties. XL413 was shown to be a highly potent inhibitor with IC50 values in single digit nanomolar range. Mor
